July 14, 2010

Top 10 Best US Presidents Of All Time #7 Through #5

Cross Posted at Left Coast Rebel
I am still counting them down to the Best US President of All Time.  Last week I ran down my list of worst presidents of all time, yesterday I shared with you my picks for Best Presidents of All Time numbers 10 through 8, today I bring you my selections for 7 through 5th.  
#7  John F. Kennedy – yes he was a womanizer, yes he was a product of an enormous and vicious political machine not seen the likes of again until the Clintons.  Yes he and Bobby John_F_Kennedywere behind the disaster at the “bay of pigs” and probably were detrimental to Marilyn Monroe’s health. Yes he picked as VP the man who would expand welfare beyond all reasonable limits and totally screw up Vietnam…But I can’t help it. Unlike Chairman Zero he really did inspire people.  One of the greatest quotes of the 20th century “ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.”  one of the few democrat Presidents to believe in cutting taxes, bringing about a time of prosperity not rivaled since the end of WWII.  Championed equal rights legislation (against the democrats in congress).  His vision put a man on the moon, the beginning of the end of the USSR.  Did successfully keep the planet out of annihilation during the Cuban missile crisis.   His strong stance against the Commies in Berlin forced Moscow to ease its pressure on central Europe.  I would take him  back in a second if I could trade him for Chairman Zero.   But I am prepared to take the heat for this pick.
james-madison #6  James Madison – The Father of the Constitution, wrote many of the Federalist Papers, helped frame the bill of rights.   Presided over the war of 1812 – our second war of independence.    This put the US on track to become a real player on the world stage.  Foresaw what would happen if things did not change regarding the southern states and civil war.  Ranking him #6 will probably be controversial, but I would rank him very near #1 as our leading Founder.
 
 
Calivin Coolidge #5 Calvin Coolidge – Became President upon the death of Warren Harding of a heart attack.   Alfred E. Smith, a Democrat, said  Coolidge was “distinguished for character more than for heroic achievement.  His great task was to restore the dignity and prestige of the presidency when it had reached the lowest ebb in our history…in a time of extravagance and waste".”   If that is not a glowing endorsement and a prescription for what we will need in 2012 I do not know what is.  Dubbed Silent Cal, because he was very stoic and did not waste words, many thought of him as lazy.   He refused to speak on the telephone as president.  He believed that meddling was the worst thing a president could do, realizing that most issues resolve themselves.  He refused to use federal power to meddle with agriculture and industry.  He was a believer in cutting taxes on farmers and producers.  1924 was a time known in the day as the “Coolidge Prosperity” Walter Lippman said Coolidge’s political genius was a talent for doing effectively doing nothing “this active inactivity suits the mood and the needs of the country admirably.  It suits all those who have become convinced that government in this country has become dangerously complicated and top heavy.”  whew…that is conservative porn right there!   Following the Presidencies of Wilson and Harding his level of Character, Honesty, and total disdain for social experimentation and government intrusion would have been fresh air indeed.   He lowered the debt nearly 25% while in office from 22 Billion to 17 billion. Federal expenditures (budget) of $5.1 billion in 1921 were reduced to $3.3 billion in 1929. He Cut taxes four out of his six years as president. The effective tax rate on the wealthy was 50 percent (1922) and he reduced it to 20 percent.  Causing revenue from that tax bracket to rise from $77 million to $230 million.
In a typical display of his famed candor and frugality of words he issued his most famous statement while on vacation in the Black hills stating,  “I do not choose to run for President in 1928” 
Once again, a man who would have been easily re-elected, choosing to give up the power without struggle.
Have a differing opinion on this list?  Who would you have put here?  What is your guess for my Top 4?
Next up…The top 4
-KOOK

Comments (10)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I will be the first to defend your Kennedy pick. Dispite his short falls, he did two things well. One, he inspired people to think beyond themselves for the greater good. Two, he was a fiscal conservative that allowed people to flourish (til the war). As for Coolidge, it may be a case his heart in the right place, but not for the country. Perhaps if he ran in 28, the depression could had been avoided or at least not as severe preventing the worse disaster til 2008, FDR. The only pick so far I have an issue with is Truman from your previous post. I would had ranked him in the top 10 WORSE or the bottom half. Other than winning World War 2, and that was left over from FDR, what did the man do that was great? Butchered the Korean War, allow communist China to grow, USSR got the bomb on his watch, the downfall of eastern europe, though FDR set that up, he didn't do much to stop it either. There was the Berlin air lift, but that was more our military than him.
3 replies · active 768 weeks ago
I too defend your Kennedy pick. The Russians cemented their WW2 gains asap following V.E day. The "iron curtain" was well established by the middle of Truman's term a decade before JFK. JFK cut taxes, stood for equality for Americans of all ethnicity, and went after corruption big time with Bobby's help at Atty General. JFK tried to get out of vietnam before it became a quagmeyer. JFK also went after the Fed (which is why I believe both he and Bobby were killed). I was hoping you would include Kennedy. I know he was elected on obama-like hype, was a womanizer and a pill junkie, but based on what he did as President, he was as close as it gets to Reagan in the 2nd half of the 20th century.

I am much easier on Truman. It was Eisenhower who butchered the Korean war by arrogantly thinking the Chi-coms would allow our army massed on their border. Ike promised Truman that China would not enter the war and ignored all evidence saying otherwise. Truman had the guts to fire Eisenhower who was immensely popular in the US. Eisenhower's promise to not draw the Chinese into the war was not widely reported. So, between dealing with rebuilding occupied europe and Japan while facing Russia and China while also dealing with an all out war in the middle east and Korea while cleaning up FDR's mess at home, Truman had quite a bit on his plate. If not for Truman, FDR's Marxist policies would have become far more ingrained in our society.
Ugh, do you mean McAurther? Though your view of the bigger picture puts Truman's accomplishments, or least what he had to deal with compared to was just in office before him, in better light.
My brain is not at full speed today (what's left of it). I often get "Ike" and "Mac" confused, but the rest of the comment was accurate. Thanks for letting me know about the mixup. I will fix them later!!
Good comments and points to both of you. One thing I have learned from doing this is that many of our presidents did both great and not so great things, some turned everything they touched to poo, and some probably were in the wrong place at the wrong time. The important thing to remember is that they are all just imperfect beings, men, and what matters is their character and their actions.
I really thought the readership would have me flogged for the Kennedy thing. I just see a lot of good he did, apparently I am not alone.
3 replies · active 768 weeks ago
3 years ago, I had a very different view of Kennedy. As for his VP pick, it was because southern "evangelist" types were did not like the idea of voting for a Yankee Catholic. LBJ was from Texas and claimed to be Protestant. That choice solidified Kennedy's ticket. Reagan picked Bush 41 as his VP. I bet that fact does not keep him out of your top 2. Reagan also botched the immigration thing badly..but we both still think he was an excellent President. As for the readers jumping on you about Kennedy, I don't see that happening. Our readership seems to be very well read and knows their history. If you forget the mystique or the name of a President like JFK and look at his actions his standing in history is fairly clear. He is another one that I think had the best of intentions. Remember that Kennedy's actions in the Cuban Missile Crisis saved the entire world. All of his advisors were pushing for nuclear war and he avoided it. Had he not, we would have never been born. It's too bad more recent Presidents weren't that strong willed.
Yea, though there are many things I don't like about Kennedy, my mother will spank me for saying this, but I think he would be more inline with the Republicans today than the radicals that the Democrats have become today. Kook, I think picking Kennedy shows how you can look beyond the R's and D's and just look objectively what the men brought to the table and judge them on those merits.
I remember in high school, they would have a quote of the day and one of them was from Kennedy.

Teacher: "we'll get to find out what Kennedy said."

Madmath1: "Get those G** D*** F****** missles out of Cuba!"

Teacher: "Basically, he did say that. . . and it worked too."
Kook:
I have been saying for about a decade if Kennedy were alive today he would a moderate Republican. Who knows if he would have gone more to the left like his two brothers, but somehow I doubt it. You will get no flak from me on this pick.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Blog Widget by LinkWithin